'Honestly' is a standout track from American Football's self-titled second album, released in 2016, over 17 years after their iconic debut album. The band, known for their intricate guitar work and melancholic melodies, returned to the music scene with a matured sound that still retained the essence of their early work. 'Honestly' showcases their signature blend of emo, post-rock, and indie influences, characterized by intricate guitar lines, subtle rhythms, and layered instrumentation. The song's production, handled by the band along with producer Jason Cupp, reflects a more polished approach while preserving the raw emotionality that fans had come to expect from American Football.
Thematically, 'Honestly' delves into the complexities of relationships and self-reflection, exploring the struggle to communicate genuine emotions. The lyrics convey a sense of longing and vulnerability, as the narrator grapples with their feelings and the fear of failing to express them. Lines such as "I could have said I loved you" encapsulate the regret and hesitation that often accompany intimate connections. This exploration of unfulfilled desires and the difficulty of honesty in relationships resonates deeply, capturing the essence of human experience with poignant clarity.
Upon its release, 'Honestly' received widespread acclaim from critics and fans alike, reinforcing American Football's status as a seminal band within the emo and indie rock genres. The song was praised for its lyrical depth and musical sophistication, with many highlighting its ability to evoke nostalgia while feeling fresh and contemporary. Critics noted how 'Honestly' and the album as a whole contributed to the ongoing resurgence of emo music in the 2010s, influencing a new generation of artists exploring similar themes. The track's legacy continues to endure, as it encapsulates the profound emotional landscape that American Football navigates, ensuring its place in the hearts of listeners and its significance in the broader musical narrative.