'That Old Feeling' was released in 1942 as part of the burgeoning big band and jazz scene that characterized the early 1940s. Recorded by Harry James and His Orchestra, the song showcases the lush arrangements and vibrant instrumentation typical of the era. The piece was originally composed by Sammy Fain, with lyrics by Lew Brown, and became a significant hit for James, who was one of the most popular bandleaders of his time. The song's release coincided with the height of the swing era, and its melodic charm and orchestral depth contributed to its lasting appeal. This period saw a fusion of jazz and popular music, and 'That Old Feeling' exemplifies that intersection with its smooth, melodic lines and rich orchestration.
Lyrically, 'That Old Feeling' captures the bittersweet nostalgia associated with love and longing. The narrator reflects on the resurgence of emotions tied to a past romance, expressing a mix of joy and melancholy. Lines such as "I get that old feeling / When I’m in your arms" illustrate the theme of rekindled affection, suggesting that certain memories can evoke powerful feelings even after time has passed. The song encapsulates the universal experience of revisiting old love, making it relatable to many listeners. The wistfulness conveyed in the lyrics is enhanced by the lush musical arrangement, which creates an atmosphere of longing and reflection.
The critical reception of 'That Old Feeling' has been overwhelmingly positive, with its enduring legacy cemented in both the jazz and pop music canons. The song has been covered by numerous artists across various genres, indicating its broad appeal and significant cultural impact. Critics have praised its sophisticated melody and heartfelt lyrics, noting that it captures the essence of romantic longing in a way that resonates with audiences even decades after its release. Its inclusion in film soundtracks and television shows has further solidified its place in popular culture, serving as a poignant reminder of the universal themes of love and nostalgia that continue to resonate through music.