'What Can I Say' was released as part of Chicago's 1982 album, 'Chicago 16', which marked a significant turning point for the band following the departure of longtime producer James William Guercio. The album introduced the band’s new sound, heavily influenced by the commercial pop-rock trends of the early '80s, while still retaining elements of their signature horn-driven style. This track, written by band members Peter Cetera and David Foster, showcases a polished production that aligns with the era's radio-friendly aesthetics. Upon its release, the song became a staple in Chicago's catalog, contributing to the album's commercial success and solidifying the band’s place in the evolving rock landscape of the time.
Thematically, 'What Can I Say' delves into the complexities of love and communication. The lyrics reflect a sense of vulnerability and introspection as the narrator grapples with feelings of inadequacy in a relationship. Lines such as "What can I say, I’m just a man" express a poignant humility and the struggle to articulate emotions in a meaningful way. The song captures the tension between desire and the fear of failing to meet a partner's expectations, resonating with anyone who has faced similar dilemmas in love. This exploration of emotional honesty is a hallmark of Chicago’s songwriting, blending heartfelt sentiment with a catchy melody.
Critically, 'What Can I Say' received a warm reception, praised for its smooth production and Cetera's emotive vocal delivery. While it may not have achieved the iconic status of some of Chicago’s earlier hits, it is often regarded as a strong representation of the band's ability to adapt to changing musical trends while maintaining their core identity. Over the years, the song has found a place in popular culture, featured in various media and covered by other artists, which speaks to its enduring appeal. The legacy of 'What Can I Say' lies in its ability to evoke genuine emotion while encapsulating the sound of a pivotal era in rock music, marking a successful transition for Chicago during the early '80s.