'What Does It Matter' is a track by the American rock band America, featured on their 1975 album 'Hat Trick.' This album, which came out at a time when America was already well-established in the music scene, showcases their signature blend of soft rock and folk influences. The band, known for their melodic harmonies and acoustic instrumentation, continued to evolve their sound with this release. Although 'Hat Trick' did not achieve the same commercial success as their earlier albums, it still resonated with fans, and 'What Does It Matter' stands out as a testament to their evolving artistry during the mid-1970s.
Lyrically, 'What Does It Matter' delves into themes of introspection and existential questioning. The song poses a series of contemplative inquiries that reflect on the nature of relationships and the passage of time. With lines like "What does it matter, if you’re not there," the lyrics evoke a sense of yearning and uncertainty, suggesting that the presence of a loved one is crucial to finding meaning and happiness. The repetitive questioning throughout the song highlights a sense of vulnerability and the human condition's inherent doubts, making it relatable for many listeners navigating their own emotional landscapes.
Critical reception of 'What Does It Matter' has been generally positive, with many reviewers appreciating its reflective quality and melodic structure. While it may not be as widely recognized as some of America’s biggest hits like 'A Horse with No Name' or 'Ventura Highway,' it has garnered a loyal following over the years, often celebrated for its introspective lyrics and gentle instrumentation. The song's themes continue to resonate, making it a relevant piece in America’s catalog, and it contributes to the band's legacy as purveyors of thoughtful and accessible rock music. As a part of the broader cultural landscape of the 1970s, it reflects the era's search for meaning and connection amidst a rapidly changing world.