Released as part of their 2014 album 'So Long, See You Tomorrow', "What If" marks a significant evolution in Bombay Bicycle Club's sound. The track showcases the band's ability to blend indie rock with electronic elements, a direction that became more prominent in their later works. The album, which was produced by the band themselves in collaboration with producer Ben Allen, received notable attention for its experimentation and maturity compared to their earlier releases. "What If" stands out with its infectious groove, driven by rhythmic guitar riffs, lively percussion, and an atmospheric synth backdrop, illustrating the band's adeptness at creating catchy yet intricate soundscapes.
Lyrically, "What If" delves into themes of uncertainty and introspection, capturing a sense of vulnerability and existential questioning. The repeated refrain of "What if I told you that I love you?" resonates as a poignant exploration of the hesitations and fears that accompany romantic feelings. The lyrics encapsulate the anxiety of expressing one's emotions and the potential consequences of such declarations. Lines reflecting on the tension between desire and fear highlight the universal struggle of opening up to another person, making the song relatable to many listeners. The contemplative nature of the lyrics invites listeners to reflect on their own experiences with love and honesty.
The critical reception of "What If" was generally positive, with many reviewers praising its infectious melody and introspective lyrics. Critics noted the song's ability to balance upbeat instrumentation with deeper emotional undercurrents, a hallmark of Bombay Bicycle Club's songwriting. The track's success contributed to the album's overall acclaim, which is often regarded as a pivotal moment in the band's discography, marking their transition into a more mature and nuanced sound. Over time, "What If" has maintained its status as a fan favorite, resonating with audiences due to its relatable themes and catchy composition, securing a place in the cultural legacy of the band and the indie music scene of the 2010s.