'What's Going On' is a cover of the iconic 1971 song originally by Marvin Gaye, released by A Perfect Circle in 2000 as part of their album 'eMOTIVe.' This album is a collection of covers that the band reinterpreted to reflect contemporary issues and emotional struggles. A Perfect Circle, known for their unique blend of alternative rock and progressive elements, brought a darker and more introspective tone to the song, which resonates with the band's characteristic sound. The release of this cover was significant as it came at a time of social and political unrest in the United States, amplifying the message of the original while infusing it with an urgent modernity that echoes the band's ethos.
The lyrics of 'What's Going On' delve deep into themes of social justice, love, and the quest for understanding amidst chaos. Lines like “Father, father, we don’t need to escalate” reflect a plea for peace and a rejection of violence, resonating with the original's call for unity and empathy. A Perfect Circle’s rendition emphasizes emotional vulnerability and introspection, which is evident in the haunting vocal delivery by Maynard James Keenan. The song serves as a commentary on societal issues, echoing the confusion and disillusionment felt during times of crisis. The repeated questioning of “What’s going on?” encapsulates a universal desire for clarity in a turbulent world, making it a poignant reflection of both the past and present.
The critical reception of A Perfect Circle's 'What's Going On' was generally positive, with many praising the band for their bold choice to cover such a revered classic. Critics noted the depth of the interpretation, highlighting the emotional weight that Keenan's performance brings to the track. The cover also sparked discussions about the relevance of the original's message in contemporary society, leading to a renewed appreciation for Marvin Gaye's work. Over the years, A Perfect Circle’s version has been recognized for its ability to bridge generations, emphasizing that the struggles of the past remain relevant today. This cultural legacy continues to inspire new listeners, ensuring that both the original and the cover resonate in the ongoing discourse surrounding social issues.